The Silent Killer
🚨 Failing to Repel the Wrong Customers is killing your Meta Ads,YouTube Tests Cost-Per-Hour Masthead, and more!
Howdy Readers 🥰
In this newsletter, you’ll find:
🚨 The Silent ROAS Killer in Your Meta Ads? Failing to Repel the Wrong Customers
📢 YouTube Tests Cost-Per-Hour Masthead
🚨 Ad of the Day
If you’re new to ScaleUP then a hearty welcome to you, you’ve reached the right place along with 50k+ CEOs, CMOS, and marketers. Let’s get into it, shall we? Oh! Before you forget, if someone forwarded this newsletter to you, don't forget to subscribe to our newsletter so you never miss out!
Together with Insense
Find your perfect niche influencers within 48 hours
Fact: Nailin' that creator-brand alignment is the secret to high-performing UGC and influencer partnerships
Problem: Manually sifting through thousands of creators to find the perfect match is a time-consuming nightmare.
Solution: Insense.
You need Insense’s carefully vetted marketplace of 60,000+ UGC creators and micro-influencers from 20+ countries across the USA, Canada, APAC, and Latin America.
Dermatologists for your skincare brand? They’ve got it! Watch collectors? LGBTQ+ creators? They’ve got it!
2,000+ e-com, DTC, and Amazon brands are using Insense to find their perfect niche creators and run diverse collaborations from product seeding and gifting to TikTok Shop and affiliate campaigns, and whitelisted ads.
Quip - received an 85% influencer activation rate (32/37 influencers posted)
Any Age Activewear - quickly matched with mature female creators aged 50+ which boosted AOV by 20%
Try Insense yourself!
Book a discovery call by February 14 and get a $200 bonus for your first campaign.
🚨 The Silent ROAS Killer in Your Meta Ads? Failing to Repel the Wrong Customers
Marketers obsess over hooks, but your first 3 seconds could be costing more than ad spend. Why? Stopping the scroll is half the battle—the real game is teaching Meta’s algorithm who to ignore. The 4-10 second window determines whether you attract high-value buyers or waste budget on tire-kickers. Ads retaining irrelevant viewers confuse Meta’s targeting, sabotaging ROAS.
The Retention Paradox: Why Losing Viewers = Winning Profits: Meta’s algorithm mirrors your audience signals. Generic retention (keeping everyone) trains it to target broadly, inflating CAC.
Data reveals ads with 40%+ retention at 10 seconds (viewers matching your ideal customer profile) drive 3.1X higher ROAS vs. “high-retention” creatives (Meta Q3 2023). Every 1% increase in qualified retention slashes CPA by $6.20 in high-AOV niches. Your ad isn’t just a pitch—it’s a lead qualifier.
The 3-Second Filter Framework
1. Verbal Guillotine (4-6s): Front-load disqualifiers like “Stop if you’ve never spent $200+ on skincare.” Unqualified viewers drop off 72% faster post-price mentions (Nielsen), sharpening targeting.
2. Niche Spotlight (7-8s): Replace generic pain points (“Tired of back pain?”) with hyper-specificity (“For CrossFit athletes with SI joint flare-ups”). Ads mentioning niche communities generate 89% higher-quality leads (Tinuiti 2024).
3. Retention Reward (9-10s): Reward loyal viewers with ICP-exclusive insights (“Replicate Dr. Peter Attia’s zone 2 training in 3 clicks”). Post-10s viewers convert at 4.7X the rate of 3s viewers (Rockerbox).
Algorithm Whisperer’s Playbook
1. Audience Hygiene: Create custom audiences of users who watched 10+ seconds of your videos. Exclude these audiences from prospecting campaigns to reduce wasted spend—Meta studies suggest this can cut costs by up to 33%.
2. Creative Scoring: Use Quality Ranking (available in Ads Manager under Ad Relevance Diagnostics) as a priority metric. Ads with high Quality Ranking often achieve 2.3X more impressions at 50% lower CPM compared to focusing on vanity metrics like Engagement Rate.
3. Budget Allocation: Analyze top-performing ads by filtering for those with ≥30% 10s retention, ≤2% CTR (to avoid curiosity clicks), and ≥5% conversion rates. Allocate 70% of your budget to these ads to maximize ROI.
15-Minute Audit Using Meta’s Hidden Tools
In Ads Manager, add columns: ThruPlay Rate, 10s Video Plays, Outbound CTR.
Sort by Cost Per Result—top performers should have ≥25% 10s retention.
Create a custom report in Ads Reporting with these fields: Campaign Name, Spend, Purchases, 10s Video Plays. Filter by objective = ‘Conversions’ and group by Campaign Name.
Red Flag: High CTR + Low Retention = Mismatched targeting.
Meta’s algorithm rewards ads that repel as effectively as they attract. By designing creatives that filter ruthlessly, you transform the platform into a self-optimizing sales machine. Every post-hook second isn’t about retention—it’s about retaining profit-ready buyers.
📢 YouTube Tests Cost-Per-Hour Masthead
Insights from SEL
YouTube is redefining premium advertising with its Cost-Per-Hour (CPH) Masthead, enabling brands to dominate its top ad space exclusively during specific hours — perfect for time-sensitive and high-stakes campaigns.
The Breakdown:
Exclusive Hourly Ad Ownership: Advertisers can purchase Masthead slots by the hour across all platforms — desktop, mobile, connected TV, and tablet guaranteeing complete ownership of impressions during crucial timeframes like major launches, announcements, or cultural events.
Redefining Premium Ad Control: The CPH Masthead shifts traditional ad strategies by giving brands 100% share of voice across YouTube platforms during purchased hours ensuring unparalleled visibility and allowing advertisers to combine hourly takeovers with regular CPM campaigns.
Flexible Budgeting and Use Cases: Flat-rate pricing for the CPH model offers predictable costs, tailored for specific high-impact use cases such as major product launches, time-sensitive announcements, holiday campaigns, livestream promotions, and cultural moment marketing.
YouTube’s CPH Masthead provides brands with unparalleled control and visibility during their most critical marketing moments aligning premium advertising with precision and flexibility.
🚨 Ad of the Day
What Works:
The phrase "Wall Art Everyone Will Compliment" creates an emotional connection by appealing to the viewer's desire for validation and admiration. It also promises a conversational centerpiece for any home space.
The warm lighting and minimalist room setup give the ad a cozy, aspirational aesthetic, making the product feel like a must-have for elevating any interior design.
What Could be Better:
While "Linen Flags" is mentioned, the ad doesn’t explain why linen flags are unique or superior. A line emphasizing their craftsmanship, material quality, or design inspiration would strengthen the appeal.
Broader Insights:
The minimal branding aligns with Settlers Club’s premium, understated vibe, making the product appear elegant and exclusive.
Advertise with Us
Wanna put out your message in front of over 50,000 best marketers and decision makers?
We are concerned about everything DTC and its winning strategies. If you liked what you read, why not join the 50k+ marketers from 13k+ DTC brands who have already subscribed? Just follow this.
At ScaleUP, we care about our readers and want to provide the best possible experience. That's why we always look for ways to improve our content and connect with our audience. If you'd like to stay in touch, be sure to follow us EVERYWHERE🥰
Thanks for your support :) We'll be back again with more such content 🥳